cash balance

Should I take out my pension early?

Before I quit my job to go back to business school, I became fully vested in my company’s retirement plan. Besides my 401(k) plan, which I rolled over to an IRA with Fidelity, I also have a Cash Balance benefit plan. Today, I have a little less than $10K in this pension account. However, I’m currently debating if it’s a good idea to collect the whole lump sum and reinvest the amount in stocks or mutual funds instead. If I do that though, I’ll take an immediate hit in the amount of a 10% early withdrawal penalty + taxes. What do you guys think? Is it wise to withdraw my pension early and invest that amount?

Like many Millennials, I always assume that my financial situation is acceptable, although it can be much improved. But in fact, I need a reality check: I don’t have an income right now and there’s barely $5K total in my checking and savings. Besides about $500 in credit card bills, I have almost $30K in student loans…towards which I’m paying ~$400 per month. So yeah, this is not what we called a sustainable situation!! My God ~ I’m in bad shape!!!

So, should I collect my pension now? I have to consider the fact that raiding my pension plan is no guarantee that I can make money off of it. There’s absolutely a chance you’ll lose money when you play the market. My #1 goal (besides getting a job) is to pay off my student loans ASAP. Given this situation, what should I do?

P.S. I actually have a low 6-figure amount in retirement funds (not including my pension) right now. This puts me ahead of peers my age but still…doesn’t help me buy makeup or tacos right now. Welp!

Advertisements